Financial statement manipulation and its implication for Shareholder Value of listed Deposit Money Banks in Nigeria
Sr No:
Page No:
19-28
Language:
English
Authors:
Blessing Ejura Success*, Success Jibrin Musa, Ibrahim Karimu Moses
Received:
2024-10-26
Accepted:
2024-11-09
Published Date:
2024-11-13
Abstract:
This study investigates financial statement manipulation and its implication for
Shareholder Value of listed deposit Money Banks in Nigeria. Focusing on Income Smoothing
(IS) and Loan Loss Provisions (LLP), the research explores how these accounting techniques
influence Tobin’s Q, a key measure of market value relative to asset replacement cost. Using
panel data from 14 banks between 2013 and 2023, the study employs a Fixed Effects Model to
analyze the relationships between these variables. The results reveal a significant positive
relationship between IS and Tobin’s Q (coefficient = 0.560, p-value = 0.020), indicating that
banks that stabilize their earnings are perceived more favorably by the market. Similarly, LLP
shows a significant positive effect on Tobin’s Q (coefficient = 0.235, p-value = 0.029),
suggesting that higher provisions for loan losses are linked to better market valuation. These
findings align with the notion that investors value stability and prudent risk management.
However, the study also highlights that excessive income smoothing or loan loss provisioning
could raise concerns about transparency, potentially eroding investor trust. This research
contributes to the limited empirical literature on creative accounting's effects on shareholder
value in Nigeria’s banking sector. The study recommends enhancing transparency in income
smoothing practices and maintaining adequate loan loss provisions to ensure long-term financial
stability and market confidence
Keywords:
Creative Accounting, Income Smoothing, Loan Loss Provisions, Tobin’s Q, Shareholder Value.